SEC Releases SCSD Self-Reporting Initiative Settlements
On March 11, 2019, the SEC announced and released settlements against 79 self-reporting registered investment advisers (RIAs), touting $125 million being returned to investors. The actions stem from the SEC’s Share Class Selection Disclosure Initiative (SCSD Initiative). The SCSD Initiative incentivized RIAs to self-report violations resulting from undisclosed conflicts of interest, to promptly compensate investors, and to review and correct fee disclosures. Specifically regarding Rule 12b-1 fees, the SEC’s orders found that the RIAs failed to adequately disclose conflicts of interest related to the sale of higher-cost mutual fund share classes when a lower-cost share class was available.
SEC Chairman Jay Clayton commented: “I am pleased that so many investment advisers chose to participate in this initiative and, more importantly, that their clients will be reimbursed. This initiative will have immediate and lasting benefits for Main Street investors, including through improved disclosure. Also, I am once again proud of our Division of Enforcement for their vigorous and effective pursuit of matters that substantially benefit our long-term, retail investors.”
While the SEC and its Division of Enforcement may be pleased, the various industry reactions during the course of the SCSD Initiative included frustration–and at times reasonably so. Tempering that frustration, is that the SEC’s focus on RIA conflicts of interest and disclosures continues. First, there is an expectation that the SEC will announce more settlements in the future for additional SCSD Initiative participants and that this may involve a grouping of a “second wave” of settlements. Second, Enforcement’s Asset Management Unit has already opened investigations into RIAs who did not self-report. Lastly, these investigations included requests for documents and information regarding revenue sharing practices and disclosures.
In conclusion, it is expected that the SEC’s aggressive enforcement efforts regarding RIA conflicts of interest and disclosures to Main Street investors will continue and has already expanded to include revenue sharing.